Provident Investment Management
books.jpg

News & Insights

 
Unadmitted Gambles

Stocks are the only thing people want more of when their price goes up. Bull markets stoke confidence. People chase the winners. More participation adds fuel to the rally, and the bull market builds on itself. 

There is nothing irrational about wanting to participate in a rising market. The problem is that no alarm sounds when prices enter extreme territory. Eventually, inevitably, prices swing to the opposite extreme. Then, as the saying goes, when the tide goes out we find out who has been swimming naked. Who had a coherent investing plan, and who was just splashing around gambling?

Read More
February Investment Comments

The year has started nicely for both stock and bond investors. In the early part of January, stocks rallied, largely from a broadening of market participation, while interest rates declined slightly. The economic backdrop for 2026 looks favorable, as moderation in both the employment market and inflation might give the Federal Reserve room to continue lowering rates. On the fiscal policy front, tax cuts and increases in government spending represent a tailwind to growth.

As we start 2026, GDP growth appears to be accelerating. The latest estimate from the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta’s GDPNow forecast for fourth quarter 2025 growth is 5.1%. Besides relatively strong consumer spending, AI data center infrastructure is having a noticeable impact on growth. A January 12th study by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis examined three Bureau of Economic Analysis data series – software, R&D, and information processing equipment – along with Census Bureau data on data center construction. The study estimates that AI categories contributed 0.97 percentage points to real GDP growth in the first three quarters of 2025. Recent announcements of additional AI data centers should further contribute to GDP growth.

Read More
The Process

It probably comes as no surprise that the Provident office is well populated with sports fans, and college football is of particular interest to many of us. Some argue that the expanded college football playoff has destroyed the appeal of the vast menu of non-playoff bowl games, but some, like me, still find a special kind of enjoyment in the quirkiness of games such as the Pop-Tarts Bowl. This year the Pop-Tarts matchup features Georgia Tech taking on Brigham Young University where three Pop-Tart mascots will be devoured by the winning team in what the bowl itself is calling the “biggest sacrifice ever.” Yes, this is very strange, but Pop-Tart maker Kellanova has leaned into weirdness and will also include a dedicated livestream on social media to track the mascots’ antics and eventual demise. Adding to odd traditions is the Duke’s Mayo Bowl, which will feature a vat of mayonnaise dumped on the head of the winning coach. The stakes may be lower than the playoffs, but these games are often fun and can lead to some laughs and a nice break from holiday stress.

Read More
January Investment Comments

The Year in Review: Resilience Amidst Fog

The financial markets demonstrated remarkable resilience in 2025, climbing a wall of worry constructed of tariff shocks, geopolitical tensions, and a historic government shutdown. While the S&P 500 index touched record highs in December, investors appear poised to enter January with caution rather than the euphoria often associated with such strong gains. Ironically, this sentiment may bode well for stock returns in 2026. 

While the indices are near their peaks, the narrative driving them has become more complex. The soft landing that seemed elusive earlier in the year has arguably been achieved, but it has been accompanied by a data fog caused by the 43-day government shutdown that ended in November, leaving investors and policymakers to navigate with limited visibility.

Read More
Year-End Financial Planning Tasks

As the calendar pages turn to December, many minds shift to the holidays, but the year-end is perhaps the most crucial time to reflect on your financial health. This period offers a unique opportunity to optimize your budget, manage your debt, reduce tax liability, maximize retirement savings, and position yourself for financial success in the new year. Here are some important actions to consider as the year concludes.

Your budget is the foundation of your financial plan. A clear understanding of your cash flow is essential for your financial health. The first step should be to analyze your bank and credit card statements for the past 12 months. This can help you evaluate the effectiveness of your existing budget and identify areas for improvement. Categorize your spending into essential and discretionary expenses. Look for recurring expenses that no longer serve you, such as unused gym memberships or subscriptions. Canceling these before January 1st provides an immediate cash infusion every month. Next, analyze your spending seasonally. Did your spending increase during the summer with travel or before the holidays with gift purchases? Use this data to create a more accurate budget for the coming year, smoothing out the expected high-cost months. With a clearer picture of your actual spending, establish a realistic budget for the next 12 months, ensuring it aligns with your core financial values and goals.

Read More
December Investment Comments

From its April tariff-related trough to its recent peak, the S&P 500 gained more than 35%, though in recent weeks the market has faced greater resistance. The market’s move higher was powered by optimism surrounding AI, strong earnings growth, and a move to more accommodative policy by the Fed as it reduced interest rates. The more recent price action has been the result of growing concern that AI isn’t yet generating enough revenue or profits to justify the spending on infrastructure, the market’s perception that the Fed will be less aggressive with rate cuts by forgoing a rate reduction in December, and increasing scrutiny on potentially stretched valuations.

These pressures resulted in the benchmark closing below its 50-day average for the first time in nearly five months, breaking its second-longest stretch above this line in over 25 years. Bitcoin, a reasonable gauge of overall investor sentiment, has sold off sharply, briefly dropping below $90,000 after hitting a record high of over $126,000 in October. In one sign of the current environment, a columnist for The Wall Street Journal openly advocated for a “good, long bear market” to cure “dangerous complacency.” Setting aside the ill-considered desire for a long bear market, a doom-seeking piece chastising investors for imprudence captures the increasingly bifurcated sentiment of investors.

Read More
Why are investors obsessed with interest rates?

When I began my career with NBD Bancorp, my colleagues would gather around the Quotron machine every afternoon to get the reading on the CRB (Commodity Research Bureau) Index. After more than a decade of high inflation, investors were attuned to any sign that it might accelerate once again. The CRB Index covered 21 commodities, and it was viewed as a harbinger of inflation. But inflation wasn’t the real worry; no, the real fear was high interest rates to combat inflation.

37 years after my trip down memory lane, investors remain obsessed with interest rates. The question is, “Why?” Interest rates are crucial to stock investors for several reasons.

First, interest rates are a good barometer for the economy and have predictive value. When an economy has been growing strongly for several years, imbalances show up. Certain components and commodities may be hard to obtain as supply has failed to keep up with rising demand. When demand exceeds supply, Economics 101 says prices go up.

Read More
November Investment Comments

The U.S. government shut down for the first time in seven years on October 1st. Politicians hope voters will blame the other party. Voters may barely notice at all. Outside the federal government, the shutdown has little practical impact on most people’s day-to-day lives. The last shutdown, which occurred during President Trump’s first term, was the longest in history at 35 days yet barely registers today as a storyline from that era.

Official economic data is not being released during the shutdown. ADP’s private employment report showed a small reduction in jobs in September, with annual pay per job up a robust 4.5%. ADP chief economist Nela Richardson underscored a disconnect between declining private payrolls and ostensibly strong second quarter real GDP growth of 3.8%, as reported on September 25th.

Read More
Artificial Intelligence Update: Skynet Fears, but Much More of the Same

I authored our Viewpoint column in September 2023 and discussed the history of Artificial Intelligence. A client recently told me he enjoyed the column and, given how AI has captivated our culture, asked if I would provide an update.

As an illustration of the power and usefulness of AI, I asked my colleague Eric Wathen to use it to generate summary reports on AI innovation over the past couple of years. They were quite helpful in putting together this column.

As a reminder from my first column, Alan Turing made several significant contributions to the field in the 1930s through 1950s, including his math machines to break coded German messages during World War II and the Turing Test to assess “intelligence.” These and other breakthroughs spurred significant research and spending that yielded little tangible progress, ushering in the first “AI Winter” from the early 1970s to early 1980s. After expert systems spurred a brief resurgence, the second “AI Winter” set in, lasting until the early 2010s. The purchase of DeepMind in 2014 by Alphabet (then Google) married machine learning with neural networks, unleashing significant research and investment that underpins all modern large language models (LLMs).

Read More
Eric Pozolo
October Investment Comments

Markets have staged a strong recovery from the April lows, with the S&P 500 up more than 30% and hovering around all-time highs. Though there has been a recent broadening out in anticipation of interest rate cuts at the Fed’s September meeting, the market has been largely driven by narrow leadership tied to the AI theme. Oracle’s most recent quarterly earnings announcement simply underscored this, as the company highlighted key contract wins related to its role as a provider of AI computing capacity that are projected to send revenue in its cloud-computing business up 700% over the next three years. Shares surged more than 35% and Oracle added approximately $250 billion to its market capitalization. AI remains very much at the forefront of investors’ minds.

AI may be the dominant theme, but markets have also responded to increased expectations for rate cuts following soft labor reports in July and August. Smaller capitalization companies, which generally are more indebted and therefore stand to benefit from lower rates, have begun to perk up. Since the beginning of August, the Russell 2000 has outpaced the S&P 500, but the small cap benchmark remains well behind the traditional benchmark for the year.

Read More
Bragging Rights and Red Flags

A friend recently sent me a video from Instagram promoting an “AI-powered day trading bot.” The pitch was clean, fast, and convincing. Fund a brokerage account, connect the bot, and sit back while the algorithm makes trades for you, no market experience required. It promised a 90% win rate and monthly returns of 5% or more. It sounded like an opportunity you’d be foolish to miss. Risk was barely mentioned, aside from a note tucked in the fine print.

Behind the slick packaging was the same story I’ve seen many times before: a shortcut that ignores context, risk, and long-term planning. My friend sent it to me more as a joke than as an investment idea, thankfully, but it illustrates what we navigate daily: a world where financial advice is everywhere, but wisdom is getting increasingly harder to find.

The CFP® Board recently conducted a survey of over 1,000 households and published the results in a study titled “Steering Clear of Financial Misinformation.” The survey found that nearly three in five Americans have made a financial decision they later regretted because of online misinformation. That number doesn’t surprise me. What used to require a phone call or a meeting now shows up in an Instagram Reel, a YouTube short, or a flashy blog post promising the “one hack the rich don’t want you to know.” We’re flooded with financial content. Some of it is helpful, even thoughtful. But a lot of it is incomplete, out of context, or flat-out wrong. And there’s almost never a disclaimer that says, “This might not apply to you.”

Read More
September Investment Comments

The S&P 500 reached an intraday high of 6,457 on July 28th, nearly triple its lowest point of 2020. The NASDAQ continued setting new highs into August and has now nearly quadrupled from its relatively recent lows. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act has been a tailwind, extending 2017’s tax cuts and providing visibility for income tax rates, state and local tax deductions, and estate taxes.

Another tailwind is earnings growth. With Q2 earnings season about complete, FactSet’s John Butters reports that 81% of companies have reported positive earnings and revenue surprises, with average earnings growing nearly 12%. Q3 estimates call for 7% earnings growth on average. Strong performance has helped justify high valuations. The S&P’s forward P/E ratio based on analyst estimates has reached 22.1, 10% above both its 5-year and 10-year average.

Read More
Blurred Lines

A few years ago, Hendrik Bessembinder, a finance professor at Arizona State, conducted a study of stock market returns over the past century that yielded interesting results. In his study of approximately 26,000 companies, which also accounted for companies that either went out of business or were acquired, Bessembinder found that approximately 60% of stocks underperformed Treasury bills, even after considering dividends. While approxi­mately 40% of stocks demonstrated relative outperformance, much of this outperformance went to offsetting the underperformance of the laggard 60%. Just 2% of companies were responsible for more than 90% of the aggregate wealth creation of the stock market relative to Treasury bills.

Of course, the impact here is skewed heavily to huge long-term winners given the results were measured by market capitalization. Nvidia’s run to a $4 trillion dollar market value would have a significantly larger impact on an updated version of this study than a mid- or small-capitalization company growing tenfold over a multi-year period. With approximately 40% of stocks outperforming Treasury bills, there remain plenty of winners to choose from, though probably not as many as some would assume. Also, the stocks that move the needle on overall stock market wealth creation eventually tend to break through to become a significant right tail outlier.

Read More
August Investment Comments

The first half of 2025 has presented investors with a paradox. Equity markets have demonstrated remarkable resilience, staging a powerful recovery from the lows of early spring, while the fundamental economic and policy backdrop has become increasingly clouded by uncertainty. This divergence between market sentiment and economic reality has created a complex and challenging environment. Follow­ing a sharp, tariff-induced correction in the spring that saw the S&P 500 fall 20%, markets executed a rapid rebound, surging 30% to all-time highs. This rally has been fueled by a persistent risk-on sentiment, with speculative appetite visible in the strong performance of recent Initial Public Offerings (IPOs) and the climb of Bitcoin back to all-time highs.

Market strength has pushed equity valuations into elevated territory. The forward 12-month P/E ratio for the S&P 500 now stands at 22.2, well above its 5-year average of 19.9 and 10-year average of 18.4. Such a premium implies a highly optimistic outlook, one that assumes corporate earnings growth will re-accelerate and policy risks will be resolved without major economic damage. This optimism, however, stands in direct conflict with a deteriorating fundamental picture, as analysts have been actively cutting their earnings forecasts. According to FactSet, while earnings growth was strong in Q1, the outlook for Q2 has deteriorated significantly. The estimated earnings growth rate for the quarter has been slashed from 9.4% to just 5.0%.

Read More
The Cost of Driving and Thriving

A recent press release from the Bureau of Labor Statistics tells me that the cost of living is rising at only a measured pace. The latest Consumer Price Index (CPI) measurement says inflation was only 2.4% over the past 12 months. Excepting a brief spurt during the pandemic, measured inflation has been consistently tame since the late 1980’s. I don’t buy it. Let’s dig into what the inflation numbers really mean.

I like talking about inflation because it’s unintuitive in surprising ways. Too, I’m animated by what I view as a conspiracy to pretend the cost of living is rising slower than it really is. It’s a minor conspiracy. There are no robes or rituals, just a tacit agreement between politicians and economists that the country does better when inflation is perceived to be lower. Some of the downward bias exerted on the data is methodological, but this Viewpoint will focus on a deeper, philosophical bias about what the concept of “cost of living” ought to mean.

Read More
July Investment Comments

On the back of easing trade tensions, markets have staged an unusually rapid recovery from a tariff-induced near bear market about two months ago. The S&P 500 rebounded more than 20% from its April low and is hovering near all-time highs. The leadership of the Magnificent Seven faltered earlier in the year, as the group entered a bear market, but the recent rally has seen the celebrated collection of companies reassert its leadership.

Despite a host of uncertainties, market participants have remained in a risk-on mode with a buy-the-dip impulse prevailing. In a sign of the current bullish market sentiment, recent IPOs have performed particularly well out of the gate. Bloomberg reports stocks of companies going public are jumping the most in their first day of trading in three and a half years. Some examples include stablecoin issuer Circle, which leaped more than 165% on the day of its $1.2 billion IPO, Chime Financial, which closed up nearly 40%, and space and defense firm Voyager Technologies, which surged more than 80%. Positioning reports suggest large money managers remain underweight equities, which could prompt a chase later in the year to close the performance gap if the current trend persists. Bitcoin, often viewed as a proxy for investor risk appetite, is also around all-time highs at more than $105,000, up about 40% from the April lows.

Read More
Social Security and Medicare

Retirement is a time to enjoy the fruits of your labor, but it also comes with important financial and healthcare decisions. Two of the most significant government programs that retirees rely on for providing income and health care are Social Security and Medicare. It is important to have a good understanding of these programs in order to make sound decisions when applying for benefits. This outline should provide a primer of these programs.

Social Security

The Social Security Act was signed into law in 1935 as part of President Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal. It was designed to provide income for retirees, people with disabilities, and survivor benefits. Today, it’s a vital source of income for retirees, assisting them in maintaining their pre-retirement standard of living. It is funded through payroll taxes, with workers and employers each contributing 6.2% of wages up to $176,100 in 2025.

Read More
June Investment Comments

Markets cheered on May 12th when the Trump Administration agreed to suspend most of the 145% tariff that it imposed on Chinese goods back on April 2nd, substituting a new 10% global base-line tariff plus a separate 20% levy tied to China’s role in the fentanyl trade, a total rate of 30%. In exchange, China will reduce its retaliatory tariff to 10% from 125%. The deal is good for 90 days as negotiations continue. The S&P 500 gained 3.3% on the news and turned positive for the year. 

Even before the China tariff reprieve, investors were bidding up the market as companies were generally reporting strong first quarter results. According to FactSet, with 90% of S&P 500 companies reporting, first quarter earnings are on pace to grow 13.4%, the second-straight quarter of double-digit earnings growth. 78% have reported actual EPS above the mean EPS estimate, above the five-year average of 77% and 10-year average of 75%. For the remaining three quarters of 2025 analysts expect earnings to grow 5.2%, 7.4%, and 6.7%, respectively, with a full year prediction of 9.3%. This is a reduction from previous full year estimates that had contemplated double-digit earnings growth.

Read More
Moving Markets and Asset Allocation

On the evening of Wednesday, April 2nd President Trump announced reciprocal tariffs for about 90 countries, with many of the tariffs far higher than previously expected. Mr. Trump’s so called “Liberation Day” led to a historic two-day selloff with the S&P 500 dropping 10.5%. The decline represents the fourth worst two-day drop since the index was created in 1957, trailing the outbreak of the pandemic in 2020, the aftermath of the collapse of Lehman Brothers in 2008, and the 1987 market crash. Going back to the 1920’s using the S&P 90, the precursor to the S&P 500, Mr. Trump’s two-day loss has been eclipsed only six times, surpassing disasters including the 1929 crash, the Nazi Blitzkrieg in 1940 and a couple of declines near the bottom of the Great Depression in 1932 and 1933. That’s keeping quite some company. On the bright side, subsequent returns have been more positive.

After more than a decade and a half of bull market returns interrupted only briefly by the pandemic and the onset of the Ukraine war in 2022, investors have been conditioned to look at declines as buying opportunities. However, in early 2025 the market looked vulnerable to the downside, regardless of tariffs. Around mid-February the S&P 500 was up about 4%, almost half the return of a typical year, and that nice performance came after two 25%+ yearly advances. At the time, the 2025 forward P/E ratio of the S&P 500 had risen to 22.2, 12% above the five-year average of 19.8 and 21% above the 10-year average of 18.3. The multiple wasn’t that far below the spectacular 26 achieved in 2000 before the dot-com crash.

Read More
May Investment Comments

The Trump administration's sudden imposition of aggressive reciprocal tariffs on April 2nd triggered significant selling pressure, causing the S&P 500 to fall by a staggering 10.5% over two days. This tariff-driven panic has secured its place among Wall Street's most notable events.

Following the initial shockwave, markets have shown signs of stabilization and recovered some losses, partly supported by subsequent announcements, including a 90-day pause on certain tariffs. The exclusion of major electronics from the steep 145% tariff levied on China helped alleviate immediate concerns about drastic price increases, contributing to a relief rally. Nevertheless, persistent trade tensions and the possibility of future escalations continue to foster caution among investors.

Read More